
Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss DRAM Price-Fixing Suit Against Micron, Samsung, SK hynix After 500% Price Surge
Judge Noël Wise denied a motion to dismiss a proposed class-action DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung and SK hynix. The 17 plaintiffs allege parallel supply cuts helped drive prices up by as much as 500%.
Judge Noël Wise has denied a motion to dismiss a proposed class-action lawsuit accusing Micron, Samsung and SK hynix of DRAM price fixing. The case, brought by 17 individuals and small businesses, can move forward after the judge found the plaintiffs' collusion claims plausible. The memory makers now have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint, with a case management conference set for January 2027.
What the plaintiffs allege
The plaintiffs say the three companies made four parallel moves that restricted DRAM supply and led to the current shortage. They cite simultaneous DRAM production cuts from October 2022 to April 2023, followed by a coordinated pivot to HBM. They also say the companies announced the winding down of DDR4 production within three months and did not expand production capacity despite prices that jumped by as much as 500% in one year.
Other factors cited include stringent customer vetting procedures, a refusal to sign long-term contracts for DRAM customers, Micron's decision to shut down Crucial, its consumer memory brand, multiple statements projecting the shortage, and the companies' involvement in previous price-fixing scandals.
Company arguments and the judge's response
Micron, Samsung and SK hynix argued that they watch each other closely because competition is tight. They said the cited moves were logical business decisions to maximize revenue during a period of great demand and were consistent with each company's independent self-interest. They also said similar behavior can be expected in a highly concentrated market where all three are reacting to the same market pressures.
The companies also argued the lawsuit is just a rerun of the same antitrust case filed against the industry in 2018. Judge Wise rejected that argument because the plaintiffs established some new evidence suggesting collusion among the three manufacturers. She disagreed with the hawks comparison, saying their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do. She decided the case is plausible enough to move forward, although this is not a final judgment.
What happens next
Both sides still have to present evidence and arguments before the court before any decision is reached. The three companies are given until December 7 to respond to the original complaint. The case management conference, which will determine administrative matters, is set for January 2027.
Sources: Tom's Hardware
SiTech — AI-powered web development
We build fast, modern websites and bring AI into real business workflows. Have a project or a question? We'd love to help.