Back

UK Tribunal Dismisses PlayStation Store Price-Gouging Lawsuit
SiTech AI Team2 min read

UK Tribunal Dismisses PlayStation Store Price-Gouging Lawsuit

A UK competition tribunal dismissed a class action lawsuit accusing Sony of inflating PlayStation Store prices, rejecting monopoly claims and potential £2 billion in damages for UK PlayStation owners.

On Tuesday, a UK competition tribunal dismissed a class action lawsuit against Sony that accused the company of inflating PlayStation Store prices. The suit, brought by consumer advocate Alex Neill in 2022 on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners, sought £2 billion ($2.6 billion) in damages and argued that Sony's control of the PlayStation Store amounted to a monopoly. Had it been successful, eligible consumers could have received around £162 ($214) each.

The claims and Sony's response

The lawsuit argued that Sony's control over the PlayStation Store ecosystem let it take a 30 percent cut, and that game prices would be about 20 percent cheaper without Sony's practices. Sony argued that supporting third-party storefronts would be prohibitively expensive while diminishing security and performance.

Why the tribunal dismissed the case

The tribunal said players had alternatives to PlayStation Store games in the form of physical copies and rival consoles. It called the argument that players were trapped in a closed ecosystem 'not credible' and rejected the claim that games would have been 20 percent cheaper. The ruling said 'there was strong evidence of a willingness of consumers to switch consoles following an increase in games prices.' The tribunal also cited Sony's research, which warned the company would lose business if its prices were not competitive with Xbox's.

Context and irony

The same competition tribunal ruled against Apple last year in a similar case, finding that the App Store's 30 percent cut on digital sales was an abuse of dominance. The irony is two-fold: Sony is planning to phase out physical copies of new PlayStation games, and the future of Xbox is murky at best.

Sources: Engadget

SiTech

SiTech — AI-powered web development

We build fast, modern websites and bring AI into real business workflows. Have a project or a question? We'd love to help.