
BIS approved 879,000 AI chip sales to China despite military company designations
Brian Mast says BIS approved 879,000 of 3.4 million requested AI chip sales to China, including to companies on a U.S. military list, while Chinese firms say new U.S. restrictions will slow AI plans.
Brian Mast, chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, said the Bureau of Industry and Security approved the sale of 879,000 of 3.4 million requested AI chips to China. The approved sales included companies that the Department of War lists as Chinese military companies, and Mast said the approvals run against the intent of U.S. export policy.
Approved sales include listed companies
BIS refused giant Nvidia applications to sell 610,000 chips to Alibaba and 508,000 to ByteDance, but allowed many other sales, including to Alibaba and Tencent. Mast said both companies are on the Department of War's List of Chinese Military Companies, which covers entities deemed military-civil fusion contributors to China's defense industrial base. Advanced chips are essential when designing nuclear weapons, stealthy submarines or advanced aircraft, and the U.S. bans exports of advanced GPUs to China so the People's Liberation Army cannot develop advanced weapons.
Diversion claims and risk assessments
Mast also claimed some Nvidia applications were attempts to sell chips to "chip-smuggling fronts" to facilitate sales to Chinese companies. The New York Times reported that some front entities are linked to Megaspeed, which is fronted by suspected Chinese intelligence asset Alice Huang, whose intimate relationship with former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang was a key factor in his resignation. Megaspeed is accused of diversion, meaning claiming to buy chips for one reason while intending to ship them to China or rent them exclusively to Chinese companies in ways that breach the spirit of export restrictions. One shared document says every Nvidia and AMD application stated that the proposed transfer posed a "low" risk of diversion. Mast's point therefore appears to be that BIS authorized sales against the clear intent of established policy and the national interest, and that Nvidia and AMD may have been too optimistic about diversion risk.
Chinese firms react to new remote-access ban
Washington adopted a new policy that outlaws allowing remote access to advanced AI chips, hoping to stop diversion and dent China's AI ambitions. Tencent said the ban will reduce the quantity of advanced compute capacity available to the company and mean its efforts to train models will slow. Alibaba CEO Eddie Wu said on the company's earnings call that the policy "will definitely have some impact on the long-term construction of Alibaba Cloud's data centers both domestically and globally." He said the long-term target of 20 gigawatts may be lowered, which will also reduce the overall capital expenditure plan. Both companies do not see the policy as creating long-term problems because they believe Chinese chipmakers will be making advanced AI hardware at scale in 2027 or 2028. Wu predicted Alibaba "will go through a phase of the largest investment in AI infrastructure" once Chinese chipmakers get up to speed.
Approved orders may not become shipments
Nvidia and AMD may not be able to sell chips to China through backdoors once Chinese chipmakers advance. Even after the companies sought BIS permission, many approved orders never resulted in shipments. That is likely because Beijing needs to approve imports and chose not to do so while its own chipmakers develop improved products.
Sources: The Register
SiTech — AI-powered web development
We build fast, modern websites and bring AI into real business workflows. Have a project or a question? We'd love to help.